It was 2019. Richard “Dick” Levy D ’60 was losing weight and wasn’t sleeping well.
Three years earlier, Levy’s wife Susan had been diagnosed with Lewy body dementia, a progressive brain disorder that causes changes in cognition, visual hallucinations, and movement difficulties. Doctors said she had three to five years to live.
Without a second thought, Levy became his wife’s primary caregiver and case manager so she could live out her life in the comfort of her own home. He administered her medications, coordinated doctors’ appointments, took care of everything around the house, and helped Susan navigate her diminishing capabilities.
At first Susan had just been misplacing things, but then she forgot how to make coffee and struggled to think through plans for the future. Her symptoms only worsened from there. “She cried a lot, and that just tore me to shreds,” Levy recalls.
Levy had thought he was well equipped to be Susan’s caregiver on his own. He had spent his career in healthcare, was on hospital boards, and had extensive resources at his fingertips near their home in the San Francisco Bay Area. But after three years, his day-to-day tasks had increased significantly. Levy was overwhelmed, and the stress was taking a toll on him—he was getting sick himself.
Dartmouth Health and Dartmouth have teamed up to establish a new system of care that aims to significantly expand the kinds of medical care people can receive in their homes. Through a set of transformative philanthropy-backed initiatives, the academic health system will soon bring primary, palliative, and acute care to patients at home, along with a support system for family caregivers.
“Home care, I think, is the future of healthcare,” says Levy, a former biotech CEO. “And Dartmouth may be the world leader in putting that together.”
The Right Place
The new system, called Dartmouth Health at Home, comprises several initiatives. Among them are the Family Caregiver Institute, Palliative Care at Home, and Primary Care at Home, all fueled by a $20 million gift from Levy to rethink how chronic care is delivered and how patients and families lead their healthiest lives. Another initiative in this new system of care will bring acute care into the home: Thanks to a $10 million gift from Kenneth R. French, professor emeritus at Dartmouth’s Tuck School of Business, Dartmouth Health is building the Vickie French Hospital at Home initiative.
The new system of care will be built by an interdisciplinary team of clinicians, care coordinators, healthcare researchers, economists, and engineers. Using the expertise of The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice, Dartmouth Health at Home will be intentionally designed to be sustainable and affordable, meeting the medical and practical needs of patients and their families in the context of their daily lives.
This initiative is coming at just the right time. There are now 61.2 million people in the U.S. aged 65 or older, according to U.S. Census Bureau data, and that number is rising. With many long-term care facilities closing or struggling to stay afloat, the demand for a healthcare model that allows people to age in place is increasing. This is acutely felt in the Northeast, as the region’s population has the highest median age in the country, and among those states, New Hampshire’s population is the second oldest, topped only by Maine. Vermont is not far behind.
“In healthcare, we spend a lot of time making patients come to us, and now we’re taking care to the patient,” says Nathan E. Goldstein, MD, chair of the Department of Medicine at Dartmouth Health, the Herman O. West Professor of Geriatrics at the Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, and co-CEO of Dartmouth Health at Home.
“As a practicing physician, I have seen firsthand that where care is delivered is often just as important as the type of care we provide,” he says. “For older adults, the home is where they heal best, feel safest, and retain the greatest sense of connectedness to their families and their community. With the launch of these programs, we will transform the way that we provide care in northern New England, and establish a blueprint for rural communities across the country. This is a prime example of providing the right care to the right patient at the right time, in the right place.”
A Hospital in Your Home
When someone suddenly becomes seriously ill or is injured, their first thought is often, “I’ve got to go to the hospital.” But that may soon change with the Vickie French Hospital at Home initiative, which will be the first program in a rural area to deliver acute care to patients at home.
“We are bringing the hospital to patients. We will send doctors to the house, we’ll send nurses, we’ll send medications, we’ll draw their labs there, we’ll send X-rays there,” Goldstein says. “We will invest in remote monitoring so we can keep track of patients and their vital signs as if they were in the hospital.”
Long travel distances in rural areas compound that challenge. The team aims to build a system that addresses the unique challenges of rurality and takes the coordination burden off the patient and their family. McKenney says: “This is truly putting the patient at the center of all that we do.”
‘Insuring’ Equitable Access
One big thing for the team to figure out is a payment model that supports home care over time, across the care continuum, and enables anyone to access Dartmouth Health at Home’s services. Right now, funding for home care is largely private or limited in scope.
Medicare, Medicaid, and commercial insurance typically cover skilled home health aides and nurses, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, and social work—but only in the short term, either when someone is recovering after hospitalization, or under hospice, when someone has a terminal diagnosis with a life expectancy of six months or less, explains Tammy Tarsa, DHA, MBA, BSN, president and chief executive officer of Dartmouth Health Home Care (formerly known as Visiting Nurse and Hospice for Vermont and New Hampshire) and co-CEO of Dartmouth Health at Home.
The AHCAH waiver can bring more complex care into the home for patients on Medicare, but it has limitations. “What CMS did in 2020 is say, okay, let’s keep people out of the hospital,” explains McKenney. To do that, she says, CMS flagged certain diagnoses as eligible for a Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) payment—often referred to as a “global payment.” With a DRG payment, a hospital is paid a set amount by the insurance company to care for a patient with a given diagnosis regardless of the patient’s length of stay in the hospital. With the waiver, CMS essentially allowed hospitals to use that same DRG payment to care for patients in their homes.
The waiver’s scope—acute diagnoses—means it can’t fully meet the needs of Medicare patients under Dartmouth Health at Home, as the programs will provide care for chronic illness and other scenarios, too.
“Home‑based health services are funded by a patchwork of reimbursement streams—each tethered to a particular payer, patient subset, or waiver—so that many essential supports remain unfunded for the majority of people who need them,” says health economist Carrie Colla, PhD, D ’01, dean of Dartmouth’s Guarini School of Graduate and Advanced Studies and the Susan J. and Richard M. Levy Distinguished Professor in Health Care Delivery Science at Geisel.
Colla and others at The Dartmouth Institute are working to figure out how to harness existing payment mechanisms to reduce gaps, ensure the financial sustainability of Dartmouth Health at Home, and reduce the financial burden of healthcare on patients and their families. The concept of global payment could play a role, she says, but in a rural area, it might not pay for itself, as each at-home provider visit takes longer when it involves driving long distances, adding to the cost of that care. Instead, Colla says, Dartmouth Health at Home will likely need to deploy a few different payment approaches to break even.
“We are the most rural academic medical center in the country,” Goldstein says. “If we can figure this out here, then we can really change the way we think about caring for folks.”
Modeling Care for Others
Figuring out a sustainable payment model may take some trial and error, says Goldstein, and certainly quite a bit of research. That’s where philanthropy is already proving to be key, providing the team with seed funding to get the programs off the ground while supporting a rigorous research and evaluation strategy. Without it, he says, these pioneering programs would need to be able to pay for themselves on day one.
Payment isn’t the only puzzle. The team also wants to make sure the initiatives truly provide positive patient experience and outcomes, reduce caregiver stress, and are built to be sustainable and replicable in similarly rural regions around the country.
That’s why an interdisciplinary team is assembling from across Dartmouth. Spearheaded by The Dartmouth Institute, the research effort is made up of coordinated teams from Geisel, Tuck, and Dartmouth’s Thayer School of Engineering.
With philanthropic support from Levy, the Dartmouth Health at Home team will start small and iterate quickly. New projects will largely follow the rapid-cycle pilot process that has proven successful through The Susan and Richard Levy Health Care Delivery Incubator. Announced with a gift from the Levys in 2020, the incubator has funded 22 pilot projects aimed at reimagining how care is delivered to patients across the Dartmouth Health system.
The Dartmouth Health at Home research and innovation team, led by Amber Barnato, MD, MPH, MS, department chair and director of The Dartmouth Institute and the John E. Wennberg Distinguished Professor at Geisel, will work in parallel with operations to demonstrate that their approaches will have both a return on investment and a meaningful impact on patients’ lives.
“Dartmouth is a demonstration site for providing a system of care like I had for Susie,” Levy says. “As we’ve seen through the Incubator, reimagining healthcare delivery can be as simple as having the right teamwork to deliver care in the home.”
And, notes Levy, who has supported healthcare initiatives both at Dartmouth and closer to his home in the San Francisco Bay area, Dartmouth is well suited to that “right teamwork” because it “is just small enough to be nimble. Dartmouth understands that cross-disciplinary teams work better than individuals working independently.”
Caring for the Caregivers
When Levy was taking care of his wife, he found that small things like counting her pills stymied him; his mind was overwhelmed, having to keep track of too many things at once, from Susan’s doctor’s appointments to figuring out what was for dinner.
Indeed, the inability to take on seemingly ordinary tasks is often why people remain in an inpatient facility, Tarsa says. Dartmouth Health at Home is building partnerships across the health system, Dartmouth, and community organizations to fill that gap.